Los Angeles Republican Clubs United
  • Current Month Flyer
  • November 8th, 2022 Election
    • HOME PAGE >
      • Join Us
      • About Us
      • In Memoriam
  • Membership Application
  • Contact Us
  • Support GOP Businesses
  • History of Betsy Ross and the American Flag
  • Clip Art
  • April 16 GotoMeeting

COMMON CORE: GOOD? OR NOT

4/4/2014

2 Comments

 
Picture
Posted by John May
April 4, 2014

At first glance, it’s easy to like Common Core.  For one thing, it is sponsored by an American hero, Bill Gates, whose foundation has donated over $400 million to pay academic researchers and social scientists to undertake studies and design programs to enable our schools to turn out graduates with upgraded skills in English, math and science. That seems ok.  And how can you not love Bill Gates? Secondly, the President of the USA is a major booster, having directed hundreds of millions of grant money to induce 90% of the states to join Common Core. So far, six states have declined.

There seems to be a widespread belief that American grade school and high school students compare poorly with an embarrassingly large number of other countries. Student achievement scores can be influenced by population mix and teachers’ labor unions, but a third source might be the education system itself. In response to that challenge, a selection of education experts have devised a program which would unify all of the school systems into one centrally managed structure. We will have, in effect, one board of education for the country instead of one for each of the fifty states.

There are lots of details in the complex program and plenty of substance for debates to come such as how to encourage “critical thinking,” and teachers of 44 states are believed to be preparing for the new regimen. The hierarchy of the national system will be empowered to decree what capabilities students should have, what study materials are acceptable and what test regimens will be applied. One notable feature is the creation of a national database to accumulate evaluation data on each student, each year. Student metadata, if you will. The totality of the program resembles that of Obama Care, in that both are complex structures of imposed rules which can be understood only after having lived with them.  

Growing curiosity about Common Core has begun to create a groundswell of concern regarding our Constitution’s main purpose: containing governmental power by dividing it among three branches and defining the responsibilities of each branch, in hope of reducing the potential for oppression. So how does Common Core threaten freedom?

The primary violation is that the federal government has no mandate or even authority to usurp the most important of state government functions, that being education. Fifty independent state systems make possible a diversified search for good educational results. The tendency of some humans to prefer collectivized, controlled programs and to dislike diversification expresses itself politically in the present confrontation. Two offshoots within the educational diversity we enjoy today are charter schools and home schooling, both of which have been producing good results. But they are anathema to the entrenched interests of the US Department of Education, which provides financial support for those who cooperate, and teacher unions which are threatened with erosion of their captive market and their political influence.     

The movement to collectivize education comes on the heels of the control of medical care and medical insurance. Both are highly complex structures of imposed rules which can be understood only after having lived with them.


2 Comments
Kathleen Smith
4/7/2014 03:47:58 am

A look into the specifics of the curriculum displays another area for heated debate!! Districts in states, not currently performing well in comparison to national numbers and those who are in desperate need of additional federal funds, seen in recent years to decrease sharply, are in favor of the Common Core Curriculum. These are districts with vast and varied challenges, looking for guidance and support to compete in the national arena. Districts on the other hand who are graduating students in a competitive pool of college applicants, enjoying acceptance into the nations renowned universities have generated some of the loudest objections from parents and teachers alike. This limited, and limiting curriculum is expected to decrease the high level of education that these districts are currently producing and therefore reducing the education product as a whole.

Reply
Joan
5/30/2014 08:48:17 am

CA is a Local Control District State. In 1972, Prop. 5 gave local control to local districts Boards of Education, now in the CA Constitution.
Thus each Board should determine whether or not to join Common Core. Is it sustainable with exorbitant costs? And invasion of student's personal data with online testing and learning? CA has the golden standards. We do not need College Readiness Standards. We already have them!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Beach Cities Republican Members

    Archives

    July 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    August 2016
    November 2015
    May 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    October 2013

    RSS Feed

Copyright © 2022 Beach Cities Republicans, All Rights Reserved.
Paid for by the Beach Cities Republicans.